Okay, it was not quite that bad. Still, it was a disappointing loss. It would have looked so much different if Greg Bird had homered in the third instead of pulling it foul. He had another chance to do damage in the fifth, but was unable to push any runs across (although he did reach on a fielding error which allowed Jacoby Ellsbury and Aaron Judge to score). He finished the night 0-for-4, dropping his batting average to .122. When he does start hitting, he’ll quickly become a fan favorite.
The Yankees lost to the Pittsburgh Pirates, 6-3, and fell 1 1/2 games behind the Baltimore Orioles. The O’s beat the Boston Red Sox, 2-0, behind a stellar pitching performance by Dylan Bundy. With the Red Sox loss, the Yankees maintained their slight hold on second place.
This was a winnable game. Even though it was an off-night for starter CC Sabathia, he kept the team in the game and lasted five innings. We cannot expect the vintage Sabathia every outing. He is, after all, a 36 year old who had to reinvent himself. This is not 2009 even if he lulled us into that thinking with his first couple of starts.
It’s hard to put a finger on any single reason for the loss. Bird’s slow start. Sabathia’s underwhelming performance. Chase Headley’s base running skills. Starlin Castro’s fielding. Aaron Judge’s six men left on base. It was just one of those nights. Shoulda, coulda, woulda…but it didn’t happen.
Oh well, today is a new day. Michael Pineda takes the mound against Pittsburgh’s talented young righthander, Jameson Taillon. Pineda will need to bring his ‘A’ game but if he has truly turned the corner, I am sure he will. With Baltimore and Boston looming next week, the Yankees cannot afford to stumble in the Steel City.
Let’s re-set this post’s image…
The Yankees need to figure out a way to get Aaron Hicks into the lineup. Limited to pinch hitting, he did single in the eighth last night. I hate rehashing why the Yankees should trade Brett Gardner, but I keep watching the San Francisco Giants and their troubles with left field. Their starting left fielder, Jarrett Parker, is out for a couple of months with a broken right clavicle. They signed Melvin Upton, Jr to a minors deal following his release by the Toronto Blue Jays, but he had surgery to repair a torn ligament in his thumb so he is down for a couple of months too. In last night’s loss to the Colorado Rockies, they were playing journeyman Chris Marrero who has struggled to find a home in the Majors for the last few years. Marrero did homer but he is only batting .152 (5-for-33). I’ve always thought Gardner would be a good fit in San Francisco. The Giants have the prospects for a match. The “reach for the sky” choice would be 23-year-old RHP Tyler Beede, but GM Brian Cashman would have to include more than Gardner to make it happen. Gardner would be easier to trade if he wasn’t hitting only .192. His bat will come around so when it does, Cashman should get Giants EVP-Baseball Operations Brian Sabean or GM Bobby Evans on the phone to strike a deal.
Credit: Getty Images
It’s good to see shortstop Didi Gregorius in rehab games. On Friday night, he was 2-for-3 with six innings of work for the High A Tampa Yankees. He’s on track to return to the Bronx the beginning of May. I am sure that he’s motivated to be back for the two game series in Cincinnati beginning on May 8th as the Reds are his original team. Of course, that’s also true for a certain flame-throwing closer as well as a YES Network announcer who proudly wore #21 in the Bronx for a few years.
Speaking of numbers, Rickey Henderson, Tino Martinez, and Robinson Cano should be very pleased to hear that their former MLB jersey has cracked the top 10 for most popular jerseys sold…thanks to Gary Sanchez. According to MLB.com, Sanchez has the ninth most popular jersey, ahead of the Los Angeles Angels star outfielder, Mike Trout. There were four Cubs, two Dodgers, two Giants, and no Red Sox in the Top 8.
Have a great Saturday! Yankees, just bring it! We want one for the win column!
“Start where you are. Use what you have. Do what you can.”
The Baltimore Orioles and the Boston Red Sox both won Thursday, so the Yankees find themselves a 1/2 game behind the O’s this morning. All three teams have ten wins, although the Orioles, Yankees and Red Sox have four, five and six losses, respectively. Surprisingly, the Tampa Bay Rays have nine wins albeit with eight losses. The biggest surprise is the cellar dwelling Toronto Blue Jays at 3-12. It’s still very early with 147 games yet to be played for the Yankees but crucial games are on the horizon.
The AL East is the only division in baseball with at least four teams over .500 although just one game separates every team in the AL Central with just a single win needed to put the bottom of the division at .500. Again it’s early, but the AL East is one of the most competitive divisions in baseball at this point.
The next week will be a challenge for the new and improved Yankees. When they complete the current three game set in Pittsburgh, they’ll head to Boston for three games beginning on Tuesday. They are certain to face Red Sox ace Chris Sale who pitched yesterday and gave a performance that justified Boston’s decision to give up their best hitting and pitching prospects over the winter. Although he didn’t figure in the extra inning decision, he went eight innings, allowing no runs and four hits. Walking only one batter, he struck out thirteen. Unfortunately, he’s in prime shape for his next start.
After the Boston series, the Yankees return home to face the Baltimore Orioles. Not to look too far ahead, but these series are followed by the Toronto Blue Jays, the World Champion Chicago Cubs, and arguably baseball’s hottest team, the Houston Astros.
Next week’s schedule represents the most difficult stretch the young Yankees have faced this year so it will be interesting to see how they respond. The Red Sox and Orioles begin a three game series tonight so on the bright side, they can beat each other up before the Yankees face them.
I am hopeful that Greg Bird’s bat starts coming around before the team gets to Boston. Aaron Judge has the “wow” factor with his behemoth home runs in games (and batting practice) but Bird remains the team’s best hitter (potentially) even if the stats don’t show it yet. I remain convinced he’ll soon be raising eyebrows with his hitting prowess but it would be nice if his offensive show could begin sooner rather than later. Maybe it’s waiting for him at Fenway Park.
Based on stats, Chase Headley is arguably the current best hitter with a .396 batting average. He’s off to a great start and admittedly, I didn’t see this coming. We’ll see if it is sustainable, but for now, he’s a vital part of the lineup. I wish I felt as good about Jacoby Ellsbury. Even though he is hitting .302, has stolen four bases and has been Joe Girardi’s clean up hitter of choice in recent games, he just doesn’t do it for me. Too often, and this is a very generalized statement without digging into the actual stats, it seems like he is underperforming in critical situations. I really have to wonder if an outfield of Aaron Hicks-Brett Gardner-Aaron Judge is better than Gardner-Ellsbury-Judge. The way Hicks is hitting right now, it is. Gardner is hitting worse than Ellsbury but this probably gets into a debate about who do you trust more.
Being in Pittsburgh tonight means that Matt Holliday’s bat takes a seat on the bench with no DH. This probably puts even more pressure to get Hicks into the lineup, especially with the pitchers taking at-bat’s. Both Gardy and Bird need to start mixing in a few hits.
Have a wonderful Friday! Let’s make this two in a row tonight!
Prior to the season, I was saying the Yankees should move veteran outfielder Brett Gardner. Now, fourteen games into the 2017 season, I am more convinced than ever he should be moved. Granted, it is not his fault that he turns 34 on August 24th (I personally blame his parents) but he does not fit into the long-term view for the new and improved New York Yankees.
For the season, Gardner is batting .205 with no home runs or RBI’s. He has stolen five bags but all things considered, his production is replaceable. The Yankees need to find room to consistently start fourth outfielder Aaron Hicks. Hicks, 27, has shown he can be a productive hitter when he regularly knows that he’ll be in the lineup. For the season, Hicks has much better numbers than Gardner (outside of the total stolen bases). Hicks has received 15 less at-bats than Gardner but only has two less hits. Hicks has three home runs on the year, with eight RBI’s. His two stolen base attempts ended in failure but regardless, Hicks has been the better player. Even though he hasn’t put up the numbers for AAA Scranton/Wilkes Barre-Barre this month, I think Mason Williams, 25, is a very capable fourth outfielder.
I would love to unload center fielder Jacoby Ellsbury but with his contract, he’s not going anywhere. We’re four years into his 7-year, $153 million contract and at this point, there’s nothing he can do for redemption (at least not in my eyes). He is what he is, and he’ll never be more, and he’ll never be that dude who tore up the league for the Boston Red Sox in 2011. That was his Brady Anderson year. Chained to Ellsbury for the foreseeable future, it means that Hicks would need to play either left or right. Aaron Judge is the awakening Giant in right so he’s not going anywhere. That only leaves left field. It makes the most sense to move Gardner and begin the outfield youth movement with full intensity. Gardner’s been a good Yankee so slap him on the back, give him a watch, and send him on his way.
I suppose the opposing point of view is that Ellsbury will be hurt at some point and it will be necessary to slide Gardner to center, creating a left field opening. At some point this season, the Yankees need to begin placing higher value in Dustin Fowler as the center fielder of the future unless they plan to discard Fowler (a mistake in my opinion) to make way for Jorge Mateo. I wish Mateo was closer to the Majors so that he could force a competition but at this point, Fowler will be ready much sooner. Since Mateo is still learning the position, he is much further behind Fowler than just levels in the Minor Leagues.
I wouldn’t want to over-expose Matt Holliday but he could still play left occasionally in a pinch. As former Yankee Lee Mazzilli once said (regrettably), “Left field is a position for idiots”. Not trying to demean the position, but there are others in the organization that can play the position as back up for Hicks, Ellsbury, and Judge. There always seems to be fourth outfielders readily available as free agents or ones that could easily (and cheaply) be had. I am not worried about the outfield depth. As we move deeper and deeper into the season, guys like Clint Frazier move closer to potential callups.
It’s time to move Gardy. Maybe not this exact minute but no later than July if not sooner.
Now that I’ve ripped Gardner for the day, he will probably go on a hitting tear.
Why is it that the best Yankees beat writers always move on? I remember loving the work of Peter Abraham on the LoHud Yankees Blog, and these days he is a Red Sox beat writer for the Boston Globe. I get it, he’s a Boston guy so it was an opportunity to go home. Then, I loved reading Mark Feinsand of the New York Daily News and listening to his podcasts. Now, he is a writer for MLB.com writing about, Egads!, other teams. Or Marc Carig of The Star Ledger moving from the Yankees to the Mets. Next, you’ll probably tell me that Brendan Kuty or Bryan Hoch have found other things they’d like to do. Sorry, just my rant about losing Feinsand. I enjoyed his time as the Yankees beat writer for the Daily News.
The win streak ends at eight. Bummer. Usually, when a starting pitcher goes eight innings and only allows three hits and strikes out ten, the end result is a win. But on a night when the other team’s starter was a wee bit better and the Yankee bats were quiet, Luis Severino took the loss as the Yankees fell to the Chicago White Sox, 4-1. The Yankees had a chance at the end with the winning run at the plate, but Aaron Judge grounded into a force out to end the game. A grand slam would have been so cool at that moment.
The Yanks still have the chance to take the series when the teams meet for the third and final time this evening.
Tuesday evening turned out to be a double loss as top prospect Gleyber Torres was scratched from the lineup for AA Trenton Thunder due to biceps tendonitis. He will undergo a MRI to determine the extent of the injury. Hopefully, the news will be favorable.
James Kaprielian underwent successful Tommy John surgery on Tuesday, so now the long road to recovery begins.
Have a great Wednesday! I think it’s time to start a new winning streak!
Credit: Adam Hunger/USA TODAY Sports
“But I like it, I love it, I want some more of it…”
He didn’t get the win, gave up a home run to a journeyman infielder, and didn’t last the length of an official game, but Jordan Montgomery has earned my respect and I am looking forward to his next start.
Montgomery was rudely introduced to the Major Leagues by Tampa’s Rickie Weeks Jr, who hit a homer with two outs and one on in the top of the first inning. It was a moment that could have sent any young pitcher (or Micheal Pineda) into a tailspin. Instead, he induced Corey Dickerson into a ground out and it was inning over. He did get into a little trouble in the third when he allowed a single to Peter Bourjos and hit Kevin Kiermaier with a pitch with just one out, however, he proceeded to strike out the next two batters to end the threat.
In the fourth inning, Steven Souza Jr doubled to start the inning. What’s with all these Jr’s in the Rays lineup? Maybe I should just call myself Fid Jr. Sorry, I digress. Back to the topic at hand, Montgomery struck out the next two batters (Kevin Kiermaier and Evan Longoria). At that point, he was pulled in favor of Bryan Mitchell. Souza Jr subsequently scored on a fielding error by Starlin Castro so the run wasn’t charged against Montgomery.
The line reads 4 2/3 innings, 5 hits, 3 runs, 2 earned runs, 2 walks and 7 strikeouts, but it doesn’t tell the story how Montgomery got tougher when the stakes were raised. He was resilient and did not allow bad plays to influence his game. Like Mariano Rivera, he had a short memory and was not intimidated by any of the Rays hitters, including slugger Evan Longoria. Some guys may not profile as top of the line aces but they are just winners. That’s what Montgomery is to me. He seems like he can be a guy you want to hand the ball to in a pressure situation. We need a few more of those.
I thought it was great that the Yankees started Montgomery’s minor league catcher, Kyle Higashioka. I am sure that helped with the transition to Yankee Stadium. Higashioka didn’t do much with the bat, but that wasn’t why he was so important to the game. Bravo to Montgomery for his first start and congrats to Higashioka for calling it. I think Jordan will be even stronger the next time out. The Yankees decision to promote Montgomery has been validated.
For the game, the Yankees did win. With the 8-4 victory over the Tampa Bay Rays, they’ve won two of two out of a three game set. The series concludes today. At the beginning of the week, I was hopeful for two out of three. Sorry, but now I want a sweep. A 5-4 record would be so much better than 1-4 or in this case, 4-5. Aaron Judge was 2-for-3 with yet another home run (his third in consecutive games). But his single was the talk of the game. The exit velocity of the ball was 116.5 MPH, the fastest base hit of 2017. Is there any doubt Manager Joe Girardi made the right decision when he picked Judge over Aaron Hicks to start in right field? All of us have known that Judge has the potential to be a monster. He’s showing us the evidence.
On the downside, Brett Gardner was injured in a collision at first base with Rickie Weeks Jr. Not sure if the collision is a product of Weeks’ inexperience at first, but Gardner will be out for a few days with a bruised jaw and strained neck. Aaron Weeks, who had completed a three game streak of starting in right, center, left figures to get a few more starts until Gardner returns. In the interim, it pushes Jacoby Ellsbury to the top of the lineup as the leadoff hitter. Ugh. Here’s hoping for a quick recovery to good health for Gardy.
Credit: Julie Jacobson/Associated Press
Pitcher James Kaprielian has met with Dr Neal ElAttrache in Los Angeles but no word has been released regarding Kaprielian’s decision. I am sure this is a very difficult decision for the young hurler. While I hope for the best result to get him back on the field again, what’s best for Kaprielian takes precedence over what’s best for the Yankees. So, whatever decision Kaprielian makes, I will support and accept.
Regarding the 40-man roster, the loser of the seat at the table is pitcher Johnny Barbato. While I was worried that Robert Refsnyder might be the player DFA’d, I did feel that it was most likely one of the lesser known pitchers. I think in my mind, Barbato is the pitcher I thought of first. Since being acquired from the San Diego Padres for reliever Shawn Kelley (now a vital part of the Washington Nationals’ bullpen), Barbato has not done anything at the Major League level. His brief appearances have not been memorable and I was surprised over the winter when the Yankees left some quality guys off the 40-man roster to protect Barbato. I assumed the Yankees saw something in the pitcher that I haven’t seen. With the number of quality arms in the organization, I have no problem with losing Barbato. Hopefully, GM Brian Cashman will be able to flip him for something of value as he’d probably be claimed off waivers by another team.
With Montgomery’s strong start, I am hopeful that Luis Severino answers the bell today against the Rays. After last year’s 0-8 record in starting assignments, I didn’t want to go into this year with Severino chasing wins again. He failed his first attempt last week but today represents redemption. I hopeful that he drops a “W” in his win-loss record so that we can get that bad boy out of the way and move into friendly debates about which young pitcher is better.
We’ll have a Bird in the lineup today so there’s no reason we can’t fly! Go Yankees, and have a great Thursday!
It seems like we were just getting excited about pitchers and catchers reporting to training camp. Now, here we are at the end of the Grapefruit League season and awaiting the first pitch to start the 2017 MLB season.
It was a very successful Spring for the Yankees. It was far better than I could have imagined. Heading into Spring, we were concerned about Greg Bird. He hit well late in the 2015 season but missed most of last year due to his shoulder injury. There was doubt about how he would perform and if the shoulder would hold him back like, say, the way Mark Teixeira’s wrist did. Bird smashed any concerns that he is ready. I know that Spring stats do not really mean much, but Bird led the Yankees with 8 home runs and was second on the team behind Gary Sanchez with 15 RBI’s. He played first base like a veteran and by all accounts, he is posed to be a future star in New York. I’ve always thought of Bird as a professional hitter and not one who will be susceptible to prolonged slumps. I am very glad to see that he is ready to fly (no pun intended).
Credit: John Raoux, AP
What can you say about Gary Sanchez? He continued the great success from last Fall without missing a beat. His bat delivered (5 homers and 16 RBI’s), and do did his arm (.983 fielding percentage in 102 innings worked, with a sub .500 stolen base percentage against him as he threw out 6 runners while only allow 4 SB’s). He is arguably the most exciting Yankees catcher since Jorge Posada or to place him higher, Thurman Munson. Good times ahead for the catching position, no doubt.
Aaron Judge held off Aaron Hicks to win right field in the Battle of Aarons. I feel bad for Hicks because I know that he needs to play every day to be successful. It’s hard to get into rhythm with limited, spot starts. But I would have been very disappointed to see Hicks get the right field job over Judge. At this point, sending Judge down to Triple A serves no purpose. He has proven himself at that level. He needs to master the Major Leagues and he can only do that by being here and playing every day. His ceiling, if successful, is so much greater than Hicks. Dating back to the days of Reggie Jackson and Dave Winfield, I love powerful right fielders at Yankee Stadium.
If I was the General Manager of the Yankees, Brett Gardner would be living in a different zip code. Nothing against Gardner, he’s been a good Yankee but his best days are behind him. He needs to open the way for younger guys. I’d prefer to start Hicks in left over Gardner, so I’d find a way to move Gardy even if the return is not ideal. The perfect scenario would be to trade Jacoby Ellsbury and move Gardner to center, but that’s not going to happen with nearly $90 million left on Ellsbury’s contract.
In the starting rotation, Luis Severino won the fourth spot but it was not an overpowering Spring performance. Last year, Severino chased his first win as a starter without success (he picked up a few wins in the bullpen but was 0-8 in his starts). I really hopeful that we do not go weeks or months trying to get that elusive first win this year. Severino has so much potential but he still leaves so many wondering if his stuff plays better out of the pen. It would be nice if he could prove those naysayers wrong (including me) to become a vital part of the rotation.
Manager Joe Girardi has delayed his decision for a fifth starter. With three scheduled off days during April including two days in the first week, a fifth starter is not needed until Sunday, April 16th at home against the St Louis Cardinals. Of the competitors for the fifth spot, only Bryan Mitchell made the Opening Day roster as a reliever. Chad Green will go down to AA Trenton while Jordan Montgomery will go to AAA Scranton/Wilkes-Barre. Both Green and Montgomery will have early April starts in the minors for further auditions. I am sure that Mitchell will get some audition opportunities through long relief. Mitchell had been my favorite for the rotation but Jordan Montgomery changed my mind. So, I am hopeful that Montgomery gets the call-up when it is time for the fifth starter.
Credit: Associated Press
I was glad to see Chasen Shreve make the Opening Day roster as the second lefty behind Tommy Layne. Well, technically the third but Aroldis Chapman doesn’t really count since he’s on the mound at the end of games regardless of who is at the plate. When the Yankees toyed with the minor league signings of Ernesto Frieri and Jon Niese, I was fearful that Shreve would be one of the odd men out. Perhaps he still is given the Yankees’ propensity for the using the Scranton/Wilkes-Barre shuttle to keep the bullpen fresh. Another young reliever I am happy for is Jonathan Holder.
Utility player Ronald Torreyes won the interim shortstop role while Didi Gregorius begins the year on the Disabled List. I am not excited about Torreyes in an every day role, but there were limited internal options. The Yankees will make room on the 40-man roster to bring up Pete Kozma to back up Torreyes, but Kozma has no bat. It did not make sense for the Yankees to trade for a shortstop since Didi will be back by the end of April or early May, and, unfortunately, prospect Tyler Wade is not quite ready. I also didn’t want to see the Yankees slide Starlin Castro back to short. He is still relatively inexperienced at second and needs to continue his work at the position. The Yankees obviously agreed as they never played Castro at short during training camp. Many thought the Yankees should have slid Castro to short to allow Rob Refsnyder to start at second. I am not sure that Refsnyder, for whatever reason, will ever get a legitimate chance in the Bronx. He was sent down to AAA for the start of the season with earlier reports that he was on the trading block.
I am not expecting this to be a playoff year for the Yankees. They could surprise and nab a Wild Card spot but I don’t think this is their year to unseat the Boston Red Sox as AL East Champions. They are still a year or two away from being a legitimate World Series contender. I do think this will be a more exciting team than last year’s team from beginning to end. The Baby Bombers proved that last year when the deadline deals moved Chapman to the Cubs and Andrew Miller to the Cleveland Indians, and Alex Rodriguez was released. It was only a preview of the excitement and energy the younger players can bring, which is further enhanced by the presence of Greg Bird this year.
Despite the quick arrival of the regular season, I am ready. Play ball!…
Soon, very soon…
We are less than a month away before pitchers and catchers report to Tampa. Sitting in Denver, I still have a few more snowstorms to go before America’s favorite pastime returns, but I am excited and looking forward to the upcoming season. The Yankees are still a couple of seasons away from being a serious World Series threat, but the season should be fun nonetheless.
There are a lot of big if’s with this year’s squad. Can Aaron Judge make the necessary adjustments at this level? Can Jacoby Ellsbury ever be the player he once was in Boston? Can he stay healthy? Will Brett Gardner be traded? Will Chase Headley be traded? Will Starlin Castro be moved to third base? Will Gleyber Torres show that he’s ready for major league action sooner rather than later? Will Didi Gregorius sustain last year’s success and show continued improvement? Will Greg Bird restore the great promise that he showed in late 2015? Will Gary Sanchez continue to show that he is arguably the best Yankee or at least show the Yankees were right in sending Brian McCann to Houston? The list goes on and on, and that’s without even getting to the pitching staff.
During the recent Winter Warm-up in the Bronx, James Kaprielian sounded like a future ace. I have long been a fan of Kaprielian’s and have looked forward to his arrival at Yankee Stadium. Last year’s injury that caused him to miss most of the season was a significant setback, but as a college player, Kaprielian is not that far away. If he can show success at Scranton/Wilkes Barre this year, there’s no doubt he’ll be making his major league debut later this summer. I would not be disappointed if Kaprielian surprisingly grabbed a rotation spot out of spring training.
Credit: Mark J. Rebilas, USA TODAY Sports
I remain hopeful that Ian Clarkin can be a future rotation piece, even at the back end. With the influx of other prospects via last summer’s trades, Clarkin’s name is rarely mentioned. But he is another one that I have hoped would achieve the big leagues. Drafted as the 33rd player in the 2013 MLB Draft, Clarkin missed part of last season with a knee injury. He is still only 21 years old so I am hopeful that he’ll bounce back for future success.
The Yankees will have a number of young arms competing for the open rotation spots, but I’d still like to see them bring in a veteran for competition. Same with the bullpen. I am supportive of the return of Boone Logan and would like to see him back in pinstripes.
Other teams are making minor moves. I liked the Miami Marlins’ acquisition of pitcher Dan Straily from the Cincinnati Reds. I remember a few years ago, I was on a flight from Portland to San Francisco. There was a guy behind me on the plane that was raving about his son, a pitcher who happened to be the minor league strikeout leader at the time for an Oakland A’s farm team. It was Straily’s dad. Straily has been through a few major league organizations since that time, but at least Miami is making moves.
I also thought the Boston Red Sox signing of former Philadelphia Phillies starter Kyle Kendrick was a sound move. Who knows if Kendrick will ever be the pitcher he once was with the Phillies, but you don’t know if you don’t try.
By not signing any veteran pitchers, the Yankees are clearly saying that they want youth to take the final rotation spots. If this team is truly dedicated to the youth movement and realistically won’t be in World Series contention for at least two seasons, I do not understand holding onto Brett Gardner. He is 33 (will be 34 this season). Speed does not age well. If the Yankees had a shot for the World Series this year, I’d say hold him. But that’s not the case. Granted, we do not know the packages that GM Brian Cashman has turned down and perhaps he has only been offered less talent. But I firmly believe in identifying undervalued assets to take advantage of potential over proven performance. There are surprises every year, but again, you don’t know if you don’t try.
Most likely, at this point, Cashman is right that no further moves will be made. I think it’s a mistake but hopefully the top young prospects will prove that the best move was no move.
I can hear those pitches popping in the catching mitts. Soon, very soon…
Sanchez had better get extra padding for that mitt…
Before the Yankees re-signed closer Aroldis Chapman, there was very little talk of what they SHOULD do. Now that Chapman is back in the fold after his brief hiatus to win a World Series championship with the Chicago Cubs, the naysayers are out in full force.
Credit: ESPN.com Illustration
For me, I am glad Chapman once again anchors the back end of the bullpen. If the Yankees had not paid him the record-setting 5 year, $86 million contract for a closer, the Miami Marlins were fully prepared to step in and pay him a million more. Like him or not, Chapman was going to get his money.
I know the current Baby Bombers Implementation Plan is in full effect and there are cheaper alternatives available. As great as Kenley Jansen is, he would have cost the Yankees their first round draft pick in the 2017 MLB Draft (then Number 17, but now Number 16 thanks to the Colorado Rockies’ signing of OF, SS, or 1B? Ian Desmond, thereby forfeiting their higher draft selection). In terms of dollars, in addition to the draft pick, Jansen would have cost nearly as much as Chapman.
Free agent and former Kansas City Royals closer Greg Holland is still available but he carries more questions as he attempts to come back from injury.
A reunion with former Yankees closer David Robertson was a possibility but the Chicago White Sox have shown they demand premium plus in trades.
Signing Chapman did not cost a draft pick or talent…only money which the Yankees have.
Chapman does carry the negative stigma of domestic violence but I do believe in second chances. He has not been convicted and by all accounts no one was seriously injured (or worse). I hope and pray it was a wake up call for Chapman. After 20 years of a Saint in the closer’s role for the Yankees, it’s unfortunate we have to deal with these issues. But give the man a chance for redemption.
I did not believe that Dellin Betances was suited for the closer’s role. My suspicions proved correct when we saw Betances stumble in September after the trades of Chapman and Andrew Miller. It may have been fatigue but I felt it was more mental. Betances is a great setup guy, perhaps one of the best in the game. Being a great bridge does not necessarily equate to being a great closer.
There is no doubt I would have preferred a reunion with Andrew Miller over Chapman but that was not going to happen. The Cleveland Indians recognize they have one of the most versatile and dependable relievers in baseball and possibly one of the most selfless guys you can ever hope to meet. But he is Cleveland property for the next few years under a very reasonable contract. If Cleveland was amenable to trading Miller, they would want no less than the premier talent they paid to acquire him. OF Clint Frazier is either first or second on any given Yankees top prospect list and P Justus Sheffield is a future mainstay in the rotation.
So regardless of the other options, I am glad that #54 found his way back to the Bronx. The trio of Tyler Clipart, Betances and Chapman may not be ‘No Runs DMC’ but they’ll be close. The Yankees still need other bullpen upgrades (I personally would like to see another reunion with the potential signing of lefty Boone Logan) but regardless of what happens, the pen will be a strength in 2017.
Next year’s going to seem like a Holliday…
After talk the Yankees would use the DH role to cycle through its position players as a form of rest, I was glad to see the Yankees make a short-term investment in former St Louis Cardinals outfielder Matt Holliday. Any way you slice it, Holliday will be a major upgrade over the now departed Alex Rodriguez. Last year, the Yankees offense was largely dependent upon two major underachievers, Rodriguez and Mark Teixeira. This year, the center of the lineup features Holliday and rookie sensation Gary Sanchez. If the Yankees can get meaningful production out of new first baseman Greg Bird and right fielder Aaron Judge, this could be a very good offense.
Credit: Google Images / STL Sports View
I am still a proponent of trading Brett Gardner. I feel strongly the team needs to open up left field for other young talent and allow Holliday an occasional start. The Yankees clearly need another starter in the rotation so if Gardner can bring in a solid #5, I’m all for it.
I think P Jason Hammel would be a good signing for the rotation but if that doesn’t happen, I am hopeful GM Brian Cashman gets creative in adding another piece. I would much rather see the team’s young talent fighting for only one rotation spot; not two. I am not convinced Luis Severino can be an effective starter but we know that he can be a very effective reliever. I would rather see Adam Warren and Bryan Mitchell in swing roles, serving as the long men out of the pen. It would be much better for Luis Cessa and Chad Green to fight each other for a rotation spot than handing it to both of them.
The heavy lifting is done for the 2017 roster but the coming weeks should bring continued improvement. No major signings or trades are expected but just little tweaks to keep this team in contention while it looks ahead to brighter days in 2019. This is what Brian Cashman gets paid to do it, and so far, he’s been doing it well…